- At a first consultation, a personal injury lawyer will ask how the accident happened, what injuries you have, what treatment you’ve had, and who you’ve already talked to about it.
- Honest, complete answers help, including about prior injuries or claims, because the insurance company will find them anyway.
- The consultation is also your chance to ask the lawyer questions about experience, fees and how the case will be handled.
A first meeting with a lawyer can feel like an interview, and in a way it is, in both directions. The lawyer needs to understand what happened and whether there’s a case. You need to decide whether this is the right lawyer for you. Knowing the questions ahead of time makes the meeting faster and more useful. Our NYC personal injury attorneys offer this first meeting free.
What Will the Lawyer Ask About the Accident?
- When and where did it happen?
- What exactly happened, step by step?
- Who else was involved, and do you have their names or insurance information?
- Were the police called, or was an incident report made?
- Were there witnesses, cameras or photos?
It helps to write down your account before the meeting, while details are still fresh.
What Will the Lawyer Ask About Your Injuries?
- What injuries do you have, and what did your doctors say?
- Where were you treated, and are you still in treatment?
- How have the injuries affected work, family life and daily activities?
- Have you missed work, and how much?
In a car accident case, the answers help show whether the injury meets New York’s serious injury threshold. Our car accident attorneys look at that question closely from the first meeting.
What Will the Lawyer Ask About Your History?
- Have you injured the same part of your body before?
- Have you made an injury claim before?
- Have you talked to an insurance company or given a recorded statement?
- Have you posted anything about the accident on social media?
These questions can feel personal, but they matter. Insurance companies search medical and claims records, and a prior injury that comes out later can hurt your credibility. A lawyer who knows about it from the start can plan around it. New York law allows recovery when an accident makes a prior condition worse.
What Should You Ask the Lawyer?
- Have you handled cases like mine?
- Who will actually work on my case day to day?
- How are fees handled, and are there any costs if we don’t win?
- How will you keep me updated?
- What do you see as the strengths and weaknesses of my case?
- What deadlines apply to my claim?
For a checklist of documents to gather before the meeting, see our guide on getting ready for your first meeting with a lawyer.
What Happens After the Consultation?
If you decide to move forward, the next steps usually happen quickly:
- A written fee agreement. In New York, contingency fee arrangements in personal injury cases must be put in writing, so you’ll know the terms before work begins.
- Records requests. You’ll sign authorizations so the firm can collect your medical records and bills directly.
- Letters to the insurance companies. The insurers are notified that you have a lawyer, so their calls go to the firm instead of you.
- Evidence preservation. The firm can ask businesses and property owners to save video and records before they’re lost.
Common Questions About Initial Consultations
Is everything I say in a consultation confidential?
Generally, yes. What you share with a lawyer to get legal advice is protected, even if you decide not to hire that lawyer.
Do I have to decide on the spot?
No. A good lawyer will answer your questions and give you time to decide. Keep in mind that filing deadlines keep running in the meantime.
Free Case Evaluation From Our NYC Law Firm
Call (212) 421-0300 or request a free case evaluation to speak with the NYC personal injury lawyers at The Law Offices of Richard M. Kenny.





