Call Now (212) 421-0300

NYC Personal Injury Attorneys

Standing up for the average New Yorker.

Call (212) 421-0300

Who Decides Your Share of Fault in a NY Car Accident Claim?

  • In a New York car accident case, your share of fault is decided by the evidence, and in the end by a jury if the case doesn’t settle.
  • Since May 26, 2026, the percentage carries more weight: in car accident lawsuits filed on or after that date, you can’t recover if your fault is greater than the other side’s.
  • You don’t have to prove you were blameless to win on the other driver’s liability, but the jury can still assign you a share, so evidence about how the crash happened matters from day one.

If you’ve been injured in a car accident due to no fault of your own, you’re most likely looking to file a personal injury claim to help you recover the compensation you need to heal. The amount of compensation you may receive depends on many factors, and one of the most important is comparative negligence. Please continue reading and reach out to The Law Offices of Richard M. Kenny to learn more about how comparative negligence affects what you can recover in a car accident claim.

Insurance companies know this, which is why the other driver’s insurer will often look for a reason to put part of the blame on you, even in a crash that seems clear-cut. Our car accident lawyers see it all the time: a claim that a driver was speeding, changed lanes too quickly or stopped short.

What is comparative negligence?

Comparative negligence is a legal doctrine that applies when both the injured person and the person being sued are found partly at fault. In a few states, an injured person who is even slightly at fault can’t recover anything. That’s called contributory negligence, and New York doesn’t follow it.

For most injury cases, New York uses pure comparative negligence. Your damages are reduced by your percentage of fault, but your fault doesn’t bar recovery. For example, if your damages are $100,000 and you’re found 30% at fault, you can recover $70,000.

Car accident cases now work differently. Under CPLR 1411(b), in a personal injury action subject to New York’s no-fault insurance law, your fault bars recovery if it’s greater than the fault of the party you’re suing, or the combined fault of all of them. Our post on how comparative negligence works after the 2026 change walks through the numbers. In short, against a single driver, at 50% you can still recover, reduced by half, and at 51% you can’t.

Who decides how much of the crash was my fault?

Early on, insurance adjusters assign their own percentages, and those numbers drive settlement offers. If the case goes to trial, the jury decides. It looks at the evidence and assigns a percentage to each party, and the court applies the rule for that type of case.

You don’t have to prove you were completely blameless to win on the other driver’s responsibility. In Rodriguez v. City of New York, the Court of Appeals held that an injured person can get partial summary judgment on the defendant’s liability without first showing that he was free of fault. The jury still decides whether the injured person was also negligent, and by how much.

Some crashes start with a presumption. A rear-end collision with a stopped or stopping vehicle establishes a prima facie case of negligence against the rear driver, who then has to offer a non-negligent explanation. In Torres v. New York City Transit Authority, a 2025 case involving a bus that hit a car from behind, the court found the defendants had raised enough of an explanation to send the question to trial. Even a rear-end crash can turn into a fight over percentages.

How is fault determined in a car accident case?

Insurance adjusters, and juries when a case goes to trial, look at a variety of evidence when deciding who was at fault, including:

  • Photos of the vehicles, the damage and the scene
  • Witness statements and the police report
  • Surveillance, dashcam and traffic camera footage
  • Vehicle data and phone records
  • Traffic laws that applied, such as right of way, signals and following distance

Your attorney’s job is to gather and present that evidence so the other party’s role in the crash is clear and your share, if any, is as small as the facts allow. Under the 2026 rule, which came as part of a wider set of changes to New York car accident cases, a few percentage points can make the difference between a reduced recovery and none.

Common Questions About Fault in NY Car Accidents

Does no-fault insurance mean fault doesn’t matter?

No. No-fault covers certain basic economic losses regardless of fault. For a claim against the other driver, which is required for pain and suffering and needs a serious injury, fault matters, and now it can decide whether you recover at all.

Can the insurance company’s fault percentage be challenged?

Yes. The adjuster’s number is a negotiating position, not a ruling. New evidence, such as video or a witness the adjuster didn’t talk to, can change it.

Talk to a New York City Personal Injury Attorney

Insurance adjusters, and in some cases juries, will ultimately decide your share of fault, and that’s why we focus on evidence from the start. Our firm has fought for accident victims over the decades, and we’re here to fight for you, too. If an accident has turned your life upside down, call (212) 421-0300 or request a free case evaluation so we can help you understand your next steps.

About our content · Editorial policy

From the Blog

Recent Blog Posts

If you’ve been injured due to the negligence or wrong-doing of another, we can provide you and your loved ones with the legal support needed to ensure proper medical attention, long-term treatment and fair, reasonable financial compensation is received for your personal injury. The initial consultation is always free. For immediate assistance, call (212) 421-0300.

American Association for Justice Million Dollar Advocates Forum Top 100 Trial Lawyers Super Lawyers BBB Accredited Business Lead Counsel Rated Trial Lawyers University National Association of Distinguished Counsel — Nation's Top One Percent, 2026
About the Firm

The Law Offices of Richard M. Kenny

Whether you need a car accident lawyer, slip and fall lawyer or legal representation for any type of accident, the NYC personal injury lawyers at The Law Offices of Richard M. Kenny can help. Located in New York City, we’ve helped thousands of individuals throughout the Bronx, Brooklyn (Kings County), Manhattan, Queens and Nassau County recover the compensation they need to receive proper medical care, treatment and quality of life after serious injury.

Learn more about our firm

$500M+Recovered
30+Years Trying Cases
24/7Available

Free Case Review

No Fee Unless We Win · Confidential

Free Case Review

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Our Offices

Main Manhattan Office
363 7th Avenue, 16th Floor
New York, NY 10001
P: (212) 421-0300F: (212) 421-1774
Get Directions →
Bronx Office
151 E Tremont Ave
Bronx, NY 10453
Get Directions →
Nearest Subway · Manhattan Office
B D F M N Q R
34 St – Herald Sq 3 blocks · 6 min walk
1 2 3
34 St – Penn Station 500 ft · 2 min walk
A C E
34 St – Penn Station 4 blocks · 6 min walk
Call Us Now