Call Now (212) 421-0300

NYC Personal Injury Attorneys

Standing up for the average New Yorker.

Call (212) 421-0300

Got Papers From an Insurer? Bring Them to Your Injury Consultation Unsigned

  • Bring every piece of paper you’ve received about the accident to your first meeting with a lawyer, especially anything an insurance company has asked you to sign.
  • In New York, a signed release generally ends your claim, and undoing one means proving something like fraud, duress or a mistake about injuries no one knew you had.
  • A medical authorization, a request for a recorded statement or a check with a release attached can all wait until a lawyer has read them.

You may want to pursue legal action if you were injured as a result of dangerous property conditions. The first step to receiving the compensation you need to heal is scheduling an initial consultation with an experienced Bronx slip and fall lawyer. Continue reading to learn more about what you will need to do to prepare for your first meeting. After a fall in a store or building, the property owner’s insurance company may contact you within days, and what it sends you belongs on the list.

What documents should I bring to my initial consultation with my attorney?

To ensure that your first appointment is productive, bring the documents that will help your attorney understand your claim. If you can, bring the following:

  • Evidence of the accident, including photos and videos, and names and contact information for witnesses
  • Medical records describing your injuries and treatment
  • A written account of the accident and what happened afterward
  • Receipts for medical costs you’ve paid
  • Information about the work you’ve missed
  • A copy of any incident report or police report
  • Your own insurance information
  • Every letter, email, form or check you’ve received from the property owner or any insurance company
  • A list of questions to ask your attorney

Why should I bring insurance papers before I sign them?

Because some of those papers can end your case or weaken it before it starts. The most important one is a release. In New York, a valid release is a complete bar to a claim it covers. In Pastrana-Ortiz v. Wemple, a 2025 Appellate Division case, a driver signed a release for the insurance company shortly after a rear-end crash, without a lawyer, while he needed money for a car to get to medical appointments. His lawsuit was dismissed because of it. He got the case reinstated on appeal only because he showed there were questions about whether he understood what he signed and about injuries that weren’t known when he signed it. That’s a hard fight to have to win.

Other papers deserve the same care. A medical authorization can give the insurer access to far more of your history than the injury at issue. A request for a recorded statement asks you to describe the accident before you’ve seen the evidence. A check can come with release language on the back or in a cover letter. A premises liability lawyer can read each one with you and tell you what it would do.

What will my attorney ask me in my initial consultation?

Just as it’s important for you to bring questions to your meeting, your attorney will ask you questions to better understand your case. Be ready to talk about:

  • What your doctor has said about your injuries and recovery
  • Whether you’ve ever filed a personal injury claim before
  • How your injuries have affected your everyday life
  • Whether you’ve given a statement to any insurance company
  • Whether you’ve talked or exchanged messages with the property owner, a manager or an insurance adjuster

How long do I have to file a personal injury claim in New York?

New York has a three-year statute of limitations for most personal injury claims. If you miss the deadline, you can lose the ability to recover compensation. Claims against the City or another public agency move much faster, often requiring a notice of claim within 90 days. That’s why it’s critical to act fast, and the first step is scheduling your initial consultation. Our post on what happens after your free consultation covers the early deadlines. Do not wait to reach out to our firm. Our legal team is prepared to walk you through each step of this process.

Common Questions About Insurance Papers Before a Consultation

Do I have to give the property owner’s insurer a recorded statement?

Generally, you don’t have to give one to the other side’s insurer. You can politely say you’ll get back to them after you’ve spoken with a lawyer.

What if I already signed something?

Bring it anyway. Whether it affects your claim depends on exactly what it says and the circumstances when you signed it.

You don’t have to sort this out alone. Call (212) 421-0300 or request a free case evaluation with The Law Offices of Richard M. Kenny. There is no fee unless we win your case.

About our content · Editorial policy

From the Blog

Recent Blog Posts

If you’ve been injured due to the negligence or wrong-doing of another, we can provide you and your loved ones with the legal support needed to ensure proper medical attention, long-term treatment and fair, reasonable financial compensation is received for your personal injury. The initial consultation is always free. For immediate assistance, call (212) 421-0300.

American Association for Justice Million Dollar Advocates Forum Top 100 Trial Lawyers Super Lawyers BBB Accredited Business Lead Counsel Rated Trial Lawyers University National Association of Distinguished Counsel — Nation's Top One Percent, 2026
About the Firm

The Law Offices of Richard M. Kenny

Whether you need a car accident lawyer, slip and fall lawyer or legal representation for any type of accident, the NYC personal injury lawyers at The Law Offices of Richard M. Kenny can help. Located in New York City, we’ve helped thousands of individuals throughout the Bronx, Brooklyn (Kings County), Manhattan, Queens and Nassau County recover the compensation they need to receive proper medical care, treatment and quality of life after serious injury.

Learn more about our firm

$500M+Recovered
30+Years Trying Cases
24/7Available

Free Case Review

No Fee Unless We Win · Confidential

Free Case Review

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Our Offices

Main Manhattan Office
363 7th Avenue, 16th Floor
New York, NY 10001
P: (212) 421-0300F: (212) 421-1774
Get Directions →
Bronx Office
151 E Tremont Ave
Bronx, NY 10453
Get Directions →
Nearest Subway · Manhattan Office
B D F M N Q R
34 St – Herald Sq 3 blocks · 6 min walk
1 2 3
34 St – Penn Station 500 ft · 2 min walk
A C E
34 St – Penn Station 4 blocks · 6 min walk
Call Us Now