- Bring what you already have: your notes on what happened, the police or incident report, photos, medical records, bills, insurance policies and any letters from an insurance company.
- Expect questions about the scene, witnesses, your medical treatment, missed work, how the injury has changed your daily life, and anything you’ve said to an adjuster or posted online.
- You don’t need a complete file to call. A first consultation is meant to sort out what’s missing, and some evidence is time-sensitive.
Seeking prompt medical care is the first step toward building a strong personal injury claim. The second is calling an attorney. If you’re still deciding who to call, it helps to know how to choose the right lawyer for your case before you book the meeting. Talking to a personal injury lawyer as soon as possible helps in several ways:
- It lets you focus on your health while your claim moves forward.
- It helps you avoid early mistakes that could hurt your chances of a fair settlement.
- It helps make sure you don’t miss a critical filing deadline.
- It gives your legal team the chance to gather time-sensitive evidence while it’s still available.
What Should You Bring to Your First Meeting?
To make your first meeting with a personal injury lawyer as productive as possible, you can prepare by:
- Writing down everything you remember about the incident
- Gathering any evidence you already have, such as the police report or photos of the scene
- Collecting receipts, records, invoices and statements for the expenses you’ve had
- Gathering your own relevant insurance policies
- Getting a copy of your medical records
- Starting a personal injury journal to track your recovery
- Collecting all correspondence with the other party or any insurance company
What Questions Will the Lawyer Ask?
It’s also wise to think through your answers to the questions experienced personal injury lawyers usually ask. The exact questions depend on the facts of your case, but they may include:
- Did police respond to the scene? If so, did they give any chemical tests or make any arrests?
- If the accident happened at a business, did you get a copy of the incident report?
- Were there any eyewitnesses? If so, did you write down their names and phone numbers?
- Have you talked to an insurance adjuster yet? If so, did you give a recorded statement?
- What were you doing in the moments before the accident? Could the other side argue you were partly at fault?
- Did you receive medical attention at the scene?
- Did you follow up with a doctor after leaving the scene?
- How severe are your injuries? Has your doctor said how long it may take to reach maximum medical improvement?
- Are you working? If so, how much work have you missed because of your injuries?
- Has anyone else in your household had to miss work because of your injuries?
- How are the injuries affecting you emotionally? Have they changed your quality of life, such as your relationship with your partner or your ability to enjoy favorite hobbies?
- Have you or your loved ones posted anything about the incident or your recovery on social media?
Common Questions About Personal Injury Consultations
Do I need my medical records before the consultation?
No, but they help. You have a right to copies of your own medical records in New York, and a provider can’t charge more than 75 cents per page for paper copies or deny them because you can’t pay. If you don’t have them yet, your lawyer can help request them.
Does a free consultation obligate me to hire the firm?
No. A free case evaluation is a chance to explain what happened, ask questions and learn your options. Whether to move forward is your decision. It’s also a good time to ask how fees work and what kinds of cases the firm handles, from car accidents to the many types of personal injury cases we take on.
If you were hurt by someone else’s carelessness and you’re thinking about bringing a personal injury claim, contact The Law Offices of Richard M. Kenny. During your free consultation, a member of our legal team will review your case, answer your questions and give you the information you need to make informed decisions.
Hurt in NYC? Our Legal Team Is Here to Help
You don’t have to sort this out alone. Call (212) 421-0300 or request a free case evaluation with The Law Offices of Richard M. Kenny.





